City found guilty on all charges
An independent Commission found Manchester City guilty of all charges over serious breaches of the Premier League's financial rules across a nine-season period (2). The club is furious (3). This is the story that shapes everything else below.
Turkish outlet Hürriyet puts the count at 114 of 115 charges (10). Italian coverage calls it an earthquake for English football (5).
City's position on the pitch has not changed: top of the Premier League on 15 points from five games, five wins from five, +8 goal difference.
Get the next Manchester City FC brief by email
This article went out to subscribers as a brief. Get the next one straight to your inbox, free.
Free · No spam · Unsubscribe anytime
Bernstein wants City out of the league
David Bernstein, a former City chairman, wants the punishment to go past fines. "The sanctions must not be only financial in nature, they must go far beyond that," he said. "If the club's appeal fails, City cannot remain in the league" (1).
German coverage reports Bernstein calling for forced relegation, with City described as raging (3).
Soriano's defence: one false accusation
Ferran Soriano rejects the lot. In a leaked internal video to staff, the City Football Group director said: "The whole Premier League case against us is based on a single false accusation" (7).
Soriano also denies wrongdoing in the wider scandal, which followed nearly eight years of investigation (4).
The long contracts were the plan for a transfer ban
City have been building for this. The club is prepared for a possible transfer ban and has used long contracts as the shield (5).
The list of players tied down includes Mateo Kovacic, Marcus Bettinelli, Geronimo Rulli, Matheus Nunes, Ruben Dias, Vitor Reis, Gianluigi Donnarumma, Phil Foden, Rayan Ait-Nouri, Rayan Chekri, Nico O'Reilly and Rico Lewis (5).
Trophies could move, Sunderland are watching
If City are stripped of trophies, the 2014 EFL Cup could go to Sunderland (9). Fabio Borini and Yaya Touré are the names attached to that final (9).
Relegation is openly on the table as a sanction (10).
Haaland, Barcelona, United: the vultures are circling
Erling Haaland reportedly sees La Liga as his preferred destination if he leaves City (8). Unconfirmed, but the guilty verdict is what put his future back under the microscope.
FC Barcelona are targeting City's biggest star in an ambitious summer plan (14). Manchester United have been tipped to poach two of City's best players amid relegation fears (13).
United's two men were here during it
Manchester United boss Omar Berrada and Jason Wilcox both held senior roles at City while the breaches were happening (6). One of them had a very prominent role (6).
The case followed Anderson and Guehi
Elliot Anderson and Marc Guehi were on international duty and the City case went with them. Thomas Tuchel said he had not discussed it with either of them. "Det har jeg ikke. Nu får jeg dårlig samvittighed, men det har jeg faktisk ikke, fordi jeg er kun fokuseret på alt, hvad vi skal håndtere her og forberedelsen af holdet," he said (12).
A press officer also blocked Tuchel from answering questions on the City case after that international window (11).
Liverpool away is next
Your team go to Liverpool on Sunday, October 11, 17:30 CEST (Premier League). Five wins from five, first in the table, and a legal fight running underneath all of it.
Camarda is on the radar
City are among the Premier League clubs monitoring AC Milan's Francesco Camarda, the 18-year-old striker. Chelsea, Tottenham, Brentford and Brighton are watching too, and Milan are not planning to sell (15).
Fan reactions
The mood on r/MCFC splits between dread and defiance. One thread tells fans to stop stressing about what they cannot control and enjoy the Rayan Chekri news instead, while another insists this is only round one and points to City's 2024 high court win over the Premier League's ATP rules as proof the fight is not over. On r/soccer the focus is on the ruling document itself, with fans pulling out the lines about Abu Dhabi government assistance to sponsors "from time to time" and sponsorship values still climbing into 2018.
